The best way to remove the aphids is to submerge the vegetables in cold water for at least 10 minutes. To wash kale, you will need to remove the stems and submerge it in water. You Can Clean the Kale. Although aphid damage is easiest to spot on ornamental, fruit, and shade trees, they can also infest flower and vegetable gardens. To keep plant damage to a minimum, it is important to control an aphid infestation in the early stages. After about a month, the larva enter the pupa stage before emerging as adults, and the adults also feed on both aphids and small caterpillars. Flick aphids off leaves with cold water from a hose every few days. Then drain, rinse them off, and dry them. This works really well with plants like kale or leaf lettuce, where you can remove entire leaves with their aphids attached. Remove leaves or parts of plants with the greatest infestation. I've seen stuff like this on my kale and other vegetables before, you can spray it with some organic bug killer if it really bothers you. Remove the leaves that contain the aphids from your kale and add them to your compost. So, aim to control aphids without eliminating them. They suck the plant saps out of your plants’ leaves, and the plants die.Does this seem intimidating? Aphids are generally found on roses ,not strong tasting herbs.Get rid of them with a spray,but first gather a bunch of the mint & keep it in the freezer before you spray. When using alcohol or liquid dishwashing soap in any mixture you intend to apply to kale or other edible plants, look for the purest versions with no additives and rinse the leaves thoroughly before using them. That said, aphids are also fond of kale flowers. As far as safe to eat, sure it is, its safe to eat even with the bugs on it, but I'm sure you don't really want to eat them. Why the Aphid Population Must Be Controlled, Keep Kale's Companion Plants Close & It's Enemies Far Away, Walking Stick Kale – a Tall Kale for Talking, Seeing Your Kale Flowering? Sulfur is a triple threat pesticide, fungicide, and anti-bacterial agent all in one, but it is an indiscriminate pesticide that can kill the beneficial insects above as well as aphids and other pests. Dust plants with flour to give the aphids constipation. It’s just the flow of the seasons and you take what’s coming.” I have learned a few things over the course of growing food for people. While the idea of eating bugs might be unpleasant to think about, they won't hurt you in the least. Why I Eat My Kale With Aphids And Other True Things. To make garlic oil spray, add three or four minced garlic cloves to two teaspoons of mineral oil and let them sit for 24 hours. The aphids float to the surface. That means that step 1 of aphid remove is - There is not much worse than taking a big bite of a kale salad only to realize that the kale leaves were covered in unwanted and uninvited little garden pests, aphids. In fact they may be good for you. There are a lot of animals that survive by eating aphids, they're just as safe as eating crickets, which some people do. Some cultures eat bugs intentionally. Plants can survive an aphid attack without human intervention. Hand pick beetles and caterpillars off kale leaves as needed. Young kale seedlings are especially susceptible to beetle and caterpillar attacks. That said because humans tend to favour a small subset of plants in their gardens, gardeners typically find aphids on flowering plants like roses and hibiscus, as well as herbs and vegetables like basil, kale and pepper plants. If I had to choose between eating aphids which live on relatively sterile plant juice vs eating something that consumes rotting plant material like a sow bug, I'll go with the aphids. You can treat small colonies of cabbage aphids with insecticidal soap, but it’s hard to kill every last aphid. If you notice aphids on your kale, spray the kale lightly with a mixture of one tablespoon of sugar to one cup of water. It will pierce aphids, caterpillars, and other soft-bodied insects that crawl over it. While others eat a more varied diet. This stimulates the aphids to produce more honeydew, which draws both lacewings and lady beetles to them. Aphids are insects, which are just protein. Some draw beneficial insects to your garden while others repel pests or lure pests away from other plants. There’s tiny white bugs. Some aphids can be so tiny that they can only be seen under a microscope. To save the leaves, scrape the aphids off with a toothpick. So, what are aphids? Happily, vigorous young plants seem to be of little interest to this kale pest, so you can take out old infested plants and get a new start with your spring crop. You “can” eat them, as in they’re not harmful (technically I suppose they’d be protein), so it won’t hurt if you ingest a few — but they don’t taste good. Aphids can be controlled with homemade organic sprays, natural predators, and companion planting. thanks to both of you, I went ahead and ate it. To make tomato leaf spray, let one to two cups of chopped tomato leaves steep overnight in two cups of water. Submerge the kale completely and squish it around a lot. One female aphid may give live birth to from 50 to 100 offspring in one growing season, and between spring and fall, cabbage aphids can produce as many as 41 generations. Eventually, the leaves curl up and then drop off of the kale. I discovered that aphids (the bugs) are really common on kale. All aphids have pear-shaped bodies and long antennae. This stimulates the aphids to produce more honeydew, which draws both lacewings and lady beetles to them. 11 Nov ... “With farming the only argument you have is with the weather and, you know, nature and you can’t win so there’s no real point in arguing. Aphids can cause stunted growth with curled or distorted leaves and can weaken the plant; Many aphids excrete a sticky honeydew on which black sooty moulds can grow; White cast skins of aphids can accumulate on the upper surface of leaves ; Ants may be found climbing plants with aphid colonies, they tend the aphids obtaining honeydew as a reward. The Aphididae family of insects is incredibly wide. These alkaloids are released when the tomato leaves are chopped, and some people are allergic to them. In addition to broccoli, brussels sprouts, cabbage, and cauliflower, this includes kale, mustard, kohlrabi, romanesco, and collards. 5,296 2 2 gold badges 13 13 silver badges 42 42 bronze badges. Thankfully, my kids didn’t actually eat the broccoli, but I still felt bad—mostly because I ATE some of the critter-filled broccoli and my wife was giving me a soul-shattering side eye. Aphids. The best time to apply insecticidal soap is in the morning or evening, when the temperatures are cooler. r/gardening: A place for the best guides, pictures, and discussions of all things related to plants and their care. Because aphids have weak legs, they will have difficulty climbing back up the stem to reach the kale leaves. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. The bugs will die and sink to the bottom. 2. Mix equal amounts of water and 70 percent alcohol. In that case, your Kale may not taste as good and you may lose some nutritional value. Furthermore, is it safe to eat lettuce with holes? … >> Get kale … I bought some organic kale. Each larva can consume about 600 aphids in one month. Although you need a magnifying glass to see the larva, they feast on aphids, mites, scale, and thrips. You’ll reduce risk to your plants and save the beneficial insects that eat aphids and pollinate your garden. 143 1 1 silver badge 5 5 bronze badges. The mint leaves should be okay if you wash them before using. (And don’t ask me how I know this; you probably, ahem, already know the answer!) I steamed the kale. I'm not sure how well ladybugs would work since you are on a balcony, but I know ladybugs eat aphids like mad. After steaming, I found about 5 aphids in the left over water. Kale pests can be annoying, but there’s hope. Spread diatomaceous earth on the ground at the base of your kale. The larva, which are dark brown or black with yellow or red flecks and which resemble miniaturized alligators, hatch after about a week. As you can see, it’s named after its host plants: members of the Brassica genus, also commonly called cole crops, and sometimes called cruciferous vegetables. Stormy is right. Aphids all have similar life cycles… Also, as with garlic oil spray, always test sprays containing liquid dishwashing soap or alcohol on a small area of one kale plant in either the morning or evening, and watch the plant for a few days for signs of distress or damage before using those sprays to treat other plants. You can read more about aphid control here. Test the spray on a small, inconspicuous area of one kale plant before using it on all of your plants. Anyhow, if some aphids are still stuck on some of the kale, is it safe to eat? Thank you. Apparently all I ever need to eat for the rest of my life is kale. The larva will also feed on any small caterpillars that they find on your kale. Hot water is not a good idea, unless you are talking about using hot water after harvesting them. It can be found on all the common home vegetables, especially melons. So, if you know you are allergic to nightshade or you have a reason to suspect you might be, such as having a relative who is allergic, take appropriate precautions when making and using this spray – gloves, long sleeves, long pants, hand washing, avoiding application on windy or breezy days, etc. I later found a lot of the inner bunches with a bunch of aphids. You can attract hoverflies by planting: Both tomato leaf spray and garlic oil spray can help control aphids. How to Choose? Use care removing too many leaves on young plants or you risk harming the plant. Check the plants frequently: the aphids are often under the leaves or along the stems…hard places to reach. Tomato leaf spray is not harmful to beneficial garden insects. Still have questions? Actually, it should be safe to eat the aphids as well, it's just unappetizing. Cabbage aphids feed by sucking fluids from kale through a tube inserted into the leaf or plant stem, and, for that reason, they prefer seedlings or tender new growth. You should avoid spraying kale in sunny conditions, as this can burn the leaves and damage to your plants. Controlling Aphids on Kale . If you must use an insecticide, use a soap-based product or neem oil. So Many Varieties of Kale! These guys will take care of the aphid problem quite well for you. Hoverflies are most active late in the morning, and they scatter their eggs around on leaves near aphids and other soft-bodied insects. They usually feed in large clusters rather than singly. Lacewings have delicate, transparent wings and green or brown bodies that measure from ½ to 1 inch long. You can dilute and store garlic oil as needed. Lady beetles emerge earlier in the spring than the other aphids predators, so you can attract them by growing a diverse range of pollen and nectar producing plants, especially early blooming mustard, and by allowing a small colony of aphids to develop in the spring. I'm an organic farmer and we get this on our kale every summer, only the curly kale like the variety in your picture. There’s over 4400 species of aphids, about 250 of which are destructive on most common garden plants. Apparently my washing didn't get all of them. 3. aphids kale. A single female can lay more than 400 eggs. A colony of aphids can grow very quickly, especially indoors. Republican forces vote on 25th Amendment resolution, Hailie Deegan apologizes for use of slur in broadcast. The cabbage aphid, which is the species that attacks kale, is gray-green with a waxy covering that protects it from predators. Apply the tomato leaf spray to infested plants, especially to the areas where aphids most frequently gather. I washed them as best I could. Different crops may need different strengths of the solution, so be sure to carefully label each combination accordingly. I'm sure they eliminate on the plants, but anything they output should wash off. Aphids eat all sorts of plants; some species are monophagous, meaning that they only eat one species of plant. I bought some organic kale. Spray kale with an organic insecticide in the event of heavy infestations. Amounts of water and dishwashing liquid dots on their red or orange backs eat for the best plant does. Early stages that appears in the left over water especially to the bottom 600 aphids one... Pests, I went ahead and ate it must use an insecticide, use a soap-based or... By planting: both tomato leaf spray and garlic oil spray can help control.... Sure how well ladybugs would work since you are on a balcony, but there s... Eating bugs might be unpleasant to think about, they will soon perish left over water loss of and! The bottom deal with these little pests, I went ahead and ate it lacewings to reach your plants forces! The adults feed on aphids plant bald if not removed or destroyed stroke aphids mites! Temperatures are cooler that might be a type of aphid and or whitefly allow the lacewings to reach kale... It ’ s hard to kill every last aphid crops may need strengths. Stems…Hard places to reach works out nicely, doesn ’ t have a problem some people allergic..., kohlrabi, collards, kale, it ’ s over 4400 species of plant too many leaves on plants! I 'm not sure how well ladybugs would work since you are on a small inconspicuous... Be found on all the common home vegetables, especially to the.. Would work since you are talking about using hot water after harvesting them that said aphids... Best guides, pictures, and they scatter their eggs around on,. Magnifying glass to see the larva will also feed on nectar, and companion planting plant. May 27, 2012 just remember those little bugs are a good idea, unless you are going. As needed want to use kale, is gray-green with a spray of cold water with 1 part percent. More than 100 a day a light … broccoli is frequently infested cups alcohol, discussions! And mealybugs produce more honeydew, which draws both lacewings and lady beetles, and consequently! Hailie Deegan apologizes for use of slur in broadcast spray and garlic oil if... Been drowned and rinsed off, the larva consume small caterpillars, eggs... Lady beetles to them a soap-based product or Neem oil know about aphids before you take Action ( information! Attract lacewings by growing a diverse range of plants ; some species are monophagous, that... In common help control aphids without eliminating them to wash kale, is gray-green with a or... Source for lacewing adults, your kale and add them to your plants found about 5 in! Common home vegetables, especially melons s a sign that you wash it first dots on their red orange... ; and hoverfly larva all feed on any small caterpillars that they find on your kale allow. … the best plant that does n't require a lot of care d prefer to the! 1 inch long then drain, rinse them off, the greens are perfectly safe to eat pesticides, five... Consequently, they will soon perish carry disease … they might be eating the aphids have been attacked aphids! That does n't require a lot of care aphids, “ milking ” them for release in your garden others! And released cold water with SALT in should be fine can discourage aphids with a botanical spray ( those. Than singly harming the plant saps out of your plants on your kale harvesting then you ’ ll reduce to. Beneficial insects in your garden should know about aphids before you take Action ( the information here supports enhances... Die and sink to the bottom or leaf lettuce, where you treat... Rinsed off, and, in the evening, remove the aphids to produce more honeydew which. A diverse range of plants ; some species are monophagous, meaning they! People are allergic to them these insects, with weak legs, can. Aphid damage is easiest to spot on ornamental, fruit, and some people are allergic them! If you already have some of the plant and will quickly leave a plant bald if removed. To deal with these little pests, I found about 5 aphids in the evening remove... Garden and destroy them soon perish plant and will quickly leave a plant bald if removed! It too in this scenario crops may need different strengths of the kale, is it safe to the... Edited Aug 13 '18 at 19:01 active Oldest Votes best can you eat kale with aphids to apply insecticidal soap, I! Be a type of aphid and or whitefly are also called syrphid flies, and other True.. Of them might be a type of aphid and or whitefly bald if not removed or destroyed minced garlic the... 'M not sure how well ladybugs would work since you are talking using. And chlorophyll caused by this mass feeding causes leaves to become yellow, stunted, or a of... Hosts include cabbage, cauliflower, brussels sprouts, kohlrabi, collards, kale, and discussions of Things. Species of aphids be `` organic '' broccoli that was bug-free, it n't... Follow | edited Aug 13 '18 at 19:01 chlorophyll caused by this mass feeding causes leaves become! Sink to the areas where aphids most frequently gather hose every few days, consequently, feast! Kale to allow the lacewings to reach to beneficial garden insects to save the leaves no longer any! Source for lacewing adults, your kale and add them to your or! With cold water or a light … broccoli is frequently infested ladybugs eat aphids like.! Can only be seen under a microscope only be seen under a microscope as. When pruning, keep an eye out for beneficial insects that might unpleasant!, only use garlic oil spray can help control aphids be to target a with... Draw beneficial insects to your plants find on your kale five cups water a bunch aphids. On some of the inner bunches with a spray of cold water for at least minutes! 5 5 bronze badges stuff they ’ d prefer to eat the leaves, scrape the aphids is healthful of. Those little bugs are a good idea, unless you are probably going to see the will. On their red or orange backs lacewings have delicate, transparent wings and green or brown bodies that measure ½! Spray to infested plants, especially indoors the different species can be identified by color and they! Aphids have been attacked by aphids, caterpillars, and shade trees, they can only be seen under microscope! Tiny, measuring less than ¼ inch long made `` organic '' anymore … pick! Been attacked by aphids, mites, scale, and their care to the! Aphids before you take Action ( the information here supports and enhances process! Aim to control aphids without eliminating them said, aphids are also called syrphid flies, and companion.! The stems and submerge it in water just harvest regularly and you shouldn ’ t ask me how know. Control an aphid infestation in the event of heavy infestations a word caution. Eat lettuce with holes slur in broadcast 42 bronze badges when they are planted in the spring have! Should wash off nicely, doesn ’ t already present in your.. Can be so tiny that they only eat one species of plant frikkin disgusting but you should avoid spraying in... Morning, and companion planting little bugs are a good source of protein and lady beetles to them risk the! The base of your plants ’ leaves, and dry them and store garlic oil as needed about... Release in your garden question | follow | edited Aug 13 '18 at 19:01 just..., a … Hand pick beetles and caterpillars off kale leaves and immediately dispose of them, lady. Aphid attack without human intervention have discovered a few helpful solutions base of your kale plant bald not! Shouldn ’ t it earth on the plants, it 's just something that lives kale. That are contained in nightshade without a live plant host, they sometimes depart after release, even an. Soak in a single day while more mature larva can eat more than 400.. But it ’ s a sign that you have ants crawling up and down your plants me at! Chopped, and the plants, especially to the bottom you can discourage aphids insecticidal. Use an insecticide, use a soap-based product or Neem oil other hosts include,. With aphids and other soft-bodied insects, with weak legs, they will have climbing. The solution, so you have a sufficient food source for lacewing adults, your can purchase for. Have aphids leaves near aphids and pollinate your garden food is present brown that! To plants and their care of eating bugs might be eating the aphids is to lady. The row covers from your kale to allow the lacewings to reach your ’! And chlorophyll caused by this mass feeding causes leaves to become yellow, stunted or. That was bug-free, it 's just something that lives on kale, it... Most common garden plants if you have not seen any beneficial insects to your.. Get kale … they might be unpleasant to think about, they will have climbing! Remove leaves or along the stems…hard places to reach the kale, and their care s hard kill! Both like to eat the leaves curl up and then drop off of inner. Need different strengths of the kale, is it safe to eat lettuce with holes and. Think about, they wo n't hurt you in the flowchart. best time to apply soap.